The Best and Worst of Times
Posted By The Editors | December 5th, 2008 | Category: Uncategorized | 4 comments
Print This Post
By John Payton:
“It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.” That is the famous first line of Charles Dickens’ A Tale of Two Cities. Dickens was talking about the French Revolution, but today we are experiencing a similar set of conflicting emotions: exhilarating excitement coupled with debilitating anxiety. The challenge is to see that we take advantage of the new possibilities born from that excitement to address some of the long-standing problems in our society and in our economy.
Just four years ago, after President Bush’s re-election, there was despair in progressive circles. Iraq, Guantanamo, Abu Ghraib, the war on terror, extraordinary renditions, the systematic destruction of the Civil Rights Division in the Department of Justice, the growing and unprecedented gap between the super wealthy and ordinary folk — all of this and more led to cynicism and despair. To have thought then that Barack Obama, a freshman Senator, would four years later launch a captivating campaign that would energize not just young people, but a whole range of dispirited people, that he would raise more money than any candidate in history, that he would defeat Senator Clinton for the Democratic nomination and then win a decisive victory over Senator McCain . . . well, very few people considered it as a realistic scenario.
But Barack Obama did win and did win decisively. Elected by all of the people to be President of all of the people. It was an extraordinary political achievement that has enormous significance for the entire country. It promises new possibilities for our democracy and for racial and social justice in our country.
That is the exhilaration.
The anxiety is nearly as extraordinary. We cringe as we listen to the news now. The week before last, we learned that Citibank was on the verge of collapse, and had to be rescued by a federal bailout. Astonishing. Other banks have already collapsed or been absorbed. We already knew that Wall Street was in ruins. We have known for a while that Detroit was in trouble. But we did not think that General Motors and Ford and Chrysler were close to bankruptcy and desperately seeking their own federal bailout. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have been taken over by the Treasury Department. In other words, they too were bailed out.
The government has launched a series of rescue plans, none successful and each associated with staggering sums of money. What we first thought would be a huge $700 billion rescue plan has now turned out to be, according to a calculation by the Associated Press, over $7 trillion either allocated or obligated by the Treasury Department or the FDIC or the Federal Reserve. Meanwhile, on the ground, people are losing their homes, their jobs, and their life savings. Retirements are being postponed or cancelled. Local governments and schools are seeing their revenues and budgets dramatically shrink. Restaurants and small shops are on life support. There is a palpable sense of fear.
The problems with our economy were evident long before the financial collapse. And those problems included danger signs for our democracy. We already had seen inner cities in crisis because of white flight and the related loss of jobs and the tax base they represented. The public schools in those communities were already in trouble – fewer than half of the students served by those schools graduate. This failure of the schools had the result of making it less likely that these students would be able to thrive in our economy or in their communities. As a consequence, there are growing numbers of people in these communities that are living outside of our economy. These realities are threatening to our democracy. This was happening at the same that we saw unbelievable wealth and luxury. That gap was evident to all, but was largely ignored.
And now this further collapse.
These circumstances present possibilities. But those possibilities have to be incorporated into the planning of the Obama administration. Yes, the unregulated greed that was the ruling principle for the last several decades must be replaced. The challenge will be to see that the economy is strengthened for those communities that have been most devastated – inner cities and poor communities. The US Treasury and the Federal Reserve have more power than we would ever have imagined; they have something close to plenary power over the economy.
How that power is applied will be critical in healing our economy. But it will do much more than that – it will also help determine if our democracy is strengthened. The point of rescuing the Citibank’s or the General Motors is to make sure that our communities are rescued. And, given the critical state of many of our inner cities, special attention must be paid to this priority.
So far, President-Elect Obama has received high marks for how he has organized his transition and begun rolling out his new administration. The economic team is largely identified, and the initial reviews are favorable. But here’s what is worrisome: there seems to be no focus on how this unprecedented financial and economic power will be used to make sure we increase social and racial justice in our society. There seems to be no concern about the health of our democracy and not just the overall health of our economy, as though there were no necessary relationship. There is.
We proudly proclaim ourselves a democracy. In remaking our economy, it is crucial that the teams assigned include members who can pay careful attention to the social justice and economic justice consequences of their actions. Our democracy demands nothing less.
John Payton is President and Director-Counsel of LDF.

Downward Mobility: The Recession’s Terrible Legacy?
Jefferson Thomas, American Hero 1942 — 2010
The “Ban The Box” Movement Scores Victories
How Injustice Works: Black and Native American Farmers Still Denied Funds by Congress
Depression and Anxiety: Is the Stuff on Your Mind Killing You
Reality and Poll Reporting are Poles Apart
The Beck-Palin Rally: Where Was The Rest of America?
Teaching Black Kids to Cope with Racism
Obama Renews Pledge to Help New Orleans Rebuild
LDF Statement Commemorating 5th Anniversary of Hurricane Katrina
Top 25 African-American Films of All Time
My Top 10 African-American TV Shows of All Time
Calvin Willis
A Fun Face?
The Red and the Black: African Americans and Cherokees in Antebellum America
Clyde Murphy: 1948 — 2010
Sarah Rector: The Richest Colored Girl in the World
Chemical Relaxers: The Facts Might Not Be So Relaxing
Spike Lee revisits New Orleans in new HBO documentary
8 Year-Old Girl’s Hair Triggers Cries of Racism But Are We Jumping the Gun?
Biloxi Schools Controversy: Punished for Achievement?
No Birth Records = Tough Road Ahead When Aging Out of Foster Care
Is That Your Child? Mothers Talk About Rearing Biracial Children
55 Years Later, Emmett Till Murder Still Haunts
The phrase “there seems to be no concern about the health of our democracy” seems unnecessarily argumentative and premature. The President-Elect has moved more quickly than any other in modern times to prepare for the transition of power and by all reasonable accounts is doing a magnificent job of juggling the legitimate concerns of economic, social and racial justice. We have just witnessed 8 years of the “worst of times and the worst of times”. By your own admission, the disadvantaged is already in a position to be treated more fairly and humanely. To date, President-Elect Obama has named Melodie Barnes (a former Ted Kennedy aide) to his team and has signaled that former Senator Daschle will head up HHS. Might I suggest that we give these individuals, as well as the to-be named heads of Labor and HUD, a chance to settle in before we declare the glass half empty. As a civil rights leader, you are right to express concern and caution. However, we are still almost 2 months away from the new administration taking over.
Responding to richmondboo, December 6th, 2008, 5:09 pm
In the piece I referenced the $7 trillion price tag that the Associated Press has calculated to be the total of the rescue efforts undertaken so far and then noted that “the US Treasury and the Federal Reserve have more power than we would ever have imagined, they have something close to plenary power over the economy.” I then turned to “how that power is applied” and noted that President-Elect Obama’s newly identified economic team has shown no “focus on how this unprecedented financial and economic power will be used to make sure we increase social and racial justice in our society.” That was the context of the language that was quoted above: “there seems to be no concern about the health of our democracy and not just the overall health of our economy.” (The last part of my language was left out.) I am sure the Obama team cares about social and racial justice.
My point was that in the crisis I would like to see attention paid to that value even as we are seeking to rescue the economy. Marginalized communities are being devastated by this crisis and there are no specific measures directed at rescuing those communities. The inaugural is six weeks from now, but the financial and economic power I referred to is being exercised right now. So, I would like to see that attention paid right now, while that power is being exercised.
All good points. However, President – Elect Obama is facing an economic and financial crisis of unprecedented proportions and his very first priority has to be to stabilize the economy. If he doesn’t, then “marginalized communities” have no chance of surviving. As Barack has repeatedly said, our Constitution allows for only one president at a time. That he has managed to do so much, as an Administration in waiting, is masterful and courageous and portends the kind of change and leadership that this great country deserves and will get on Jan 20. We should all continue to encourage the President – Elect to show concern for the disadvantaged as he has done for the U.S. auto industry and most recently with respect to Republic Windows in Chicago; but what civil rights leaders should be most focused on is creating a coordinated and comprehensive plan for the President-Elect that outlines the “specific measures directed at rescuing [marginalized] communities” that you reference above. If our civil rights leaders don’t exercise leadership in this area, then who will? And if representatives of other progressive constituencies get their concrete plans in to the Administration while civil rights leaders are blogging, then whom do we ultimately have to blame?
Responding to richmondboo December 10th, 2008, 12:04 pm
The comment has missed the main point: The current administration is right now exercising the enormous financial power I described and is apparently doing so without regard to concerns about economic and racial justice. Of course stabilizing the economy is the highest priority, but, as President Elect Obama said about this very crisis: the American people expect that a President can do more than one thing at a time. I am sure that poses no problem for Barack Obama. The transition team appears to be interfacing with the current economic team on a daily basis and could incorporate these concerns about economic and racial justice into their suggestions and input. We, and others in the civil rights community, have, on multiple occasions, communicated these points, in some detail, to the Obama transition. We believe we have had a very receptive audience.