Toward a New View of Muslim Women
Posted By The Editors | June 16th, 2009 | Category: LDF Voices, Year in Review | 7 comments
Print This Post
By Nura Sediqe
“I reject the view of some….that a woman who chooses to cover her hair is somehow less equal.”
–President Barack Obama, Cairo, Egypt
President Obama’s words in his June 4 address in Cairo, Egypt have brought a refreshing change in the rhetoric that is commonly utilized when discussing women and Islam. They were only a few simple lines in a long and extensive speech addressing a variety of pressing policy issues, but for Muslim women like myself, there was a pause….while we were all thinking, “Did he really just say that?”
It’s a sad reality to think that we should be surprised by such a simple statement. But for too long, Muslim women have largely been discussed in a specific light. Professor Mohja Kahf, a well known Muslim-American author, has reflected on, how the movie industry and mainstream literature have portrayed, as she describes, her (Muslim woman) as powerless to speak, but for the Westerner speaking on her behalf. Eliminate the subculture of women from the picture, all her empowering relationships with sisters, grandmothers, and friends. Ignore homegrown non-Western feminisms. Include no kindly brothers or uncles and no Muslim men who champion women’s rights.”
It would be almost excusable if we could simply blame Hollywood for this problem, but we see this same angle with the news. Events discussed with Muslim women as the main character predominantly portray the woman as a victim. It is reminiscent of the pervasive stereotypes of minorities and women of color.
The “black welfare mother” was a common image that communications and public opinion scholars feel had a startling effect on what the public thought of African-American women, as Shanto Iyengar explored in his book, Is Anyone Responsible? How Television Frames Political Issues.
It seems that, too often, women of color and misunderstood groups are more the victims of media than the real situations they are struggling with.
There was a recent article on the front page of The New York Times that exemplified how even prestigious papers utilize such stereotypical dynamics. It featured an Afghan woman, yet again, being denied rights because of what? Why, according to the story, naturally because of her religion-Islam.
Such an emphasis on this dynamic makes us forget the resilience of these females and ignorantly associates these conditions with a religion. It takes the emphasis away from the real problems at hand, and does a greater disservice to the individuals who are suffering.
Ironically, the same religion that is demonized for oppressing women is the one that has historically produced great examples of women who have been empowered by Islam to serve as role models for communities globally, from Betty Shabazz to contemporary leaders such as Dr. Ingrid Mattson, president of ISNA, the largest Muslim organization in North America.
Or my own personal role model, my mother, Salmenna Sediqe, who was recently elected President of the Islamic community in Toledo, Ohio. She is a survivor of war who managed not only to flee her war-ridden country but also to move beyond the painful circumstances of her home country and continue her civic engagement, empowered by the very religion that is often viewed as being responsible for a lack of women’s rights. And yes, she has done this all whilst choosing to cover her hair.
Their voices and words continue to inspire a new generation of women. President Obama’s words are powerful precisely because, as women who made the active choice to cover, they are faced daily with a barrage of misperceptions. These women deal with attitudes from the pitying glances of those who are trying to assess who “forced this upon them” to broad misperceptions that women who choose to cover seek to lead a quietly domestic lifestyle. People are sincerely surprised when they encounter covered women working as Congressional staff members or medical doctors, and there are endless humorous stories these women can share about their experiences.
It is doubtful that most members of the public, upon first glancing upon a woman such as Dalia Mogahed (who wears the headscarf), would guess that she is an advisor to President Obama. For some reason, making the choice to cover automatically puts you in a category of ignorance or lack of motivation.
Even worse, young women with aspirations for a fruitful career are forced to work twice as hard to achieve the same goals as other individuals. Women with advancing careers are advised, “off the record”, that they may advance further if they simply remove their scarves.
President Obama went on to say, in that same speech, that “it is important…to avoid impeding Muslim citizens from practicing religion as they see fit-for instance, by dictating what clothes a Muslim woman should wear. We cannot disguise hostility towards any religion behind the pretence of liberalism.”
As President Obama’s words were a step toward a new beginning, I hope that the media and public are ready to take a new step in understanding and accepting the different nuances of minority groups and peoples of color and, in this case, Muslim women.
Nura Sediqe is Research Director for the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, Inc.
Urgent Message from LDF: Why This Census Counts More Than Ever
No Money in the Bank: Black Women, Wealth and Assets
Juanita Goggins: South Carolina Civil Rights Icon Dies Tragically. But Why?
Notes from SleezaCard
New Book Explores Link Between Blackness and Crime
Cartoon: March 16, 2010
Arthur Mumphrey
Mission Critical: Succeeding at Black America’s Last Chance
International Women’s Day: Crossing Bridges for Women Around the World
Detroit Diary: Don’t Leave Young Workers Behind
Top 25 African-American Films of All Time
My Top 10 African-American TV Shows of All Time
“Precious” and the Oscars
What the Amy Bishop Case Says About Race and Crime
Sarah Rector: The Richest Colored Girl in the World
‘If You Learned It, Then You Should Have Got an A On It’
A Fun Face?
‘I Can’t Believe You Brought Home a White Boy’
Chemical Relaxers: The Facts Might Not Be So Relaxing
LDF Defends Chicago Black Firefighters
Will the ‘Real’ Michelle Obama Please Stand Up?
Is That Your Child? Mothers Talk About Rearing Biracial Children
From Orange Mint and Honey to Sins of the Mother: The Power of Story Endures
Father of African-American Cinema Receives Stamp of Greatness
I am not a Muslim, but I find that this post was written very well and really opens peoples eyes as to how Muslim women are seen and treated. My mother is one of the people who think that Muslim women are completely helpless, and it makes me quite sad. I hope that with the younger generations, and those yet to come, our world opens our eyes to things like this. Thank you for taking the time to write this.
I love this article. I am gay and Christian but I have to say that I love seeing women who wear the headscarf. Coming from a home where I seen picture if Mary all over the place I find it beautiful that this tradition is in a way carried out today by the women who choose the wear the veil. If you truly believe in freedom then we embrace the rights of women who choose to wear the veil. I admire and respect them deeply. Morality is the observation of another persons right!
Very well written and thought provoking article that explores the present perceptions and future possibilities facing muslim women everywhere! Thank you
Nice article…It is brief yet it covers a whole lot…well written.
Thanks for taking the time and helping people understand some facts
Beautifully written article!
It gave me goosebumps and a huge dose of inspiration.
Obama has been very mature in his attitude towards the Muslim world. A positive trait that is often lost in criticism of his economic reforms.
This is all good and well for those Muslim women who have a choice.
The problem is with the millions of poor, uneducated women who do not have the same choices and opportunities as the author above.
Then we have the women in places like Afghanistan and the Sinai who are forced to wear the hijab and the burqa. These women do not have a choice. These women are subjugated by the medieval minds of men who have no respect for women and see them as only a vessel for their seed in the production of offspring.
It is all good and well that this privileged woman and women like her have these choices. Their stance in favor of the veil is seen as and used by these oppressive forces to enslave the minds of millions of women. These men use Islam and the hijab and the burqa as a means to keep their boot heals squarely across the neck of women in all of the lands of Islam
Islam is like any other religion. There exists both beauty and ugliness within the pages of all religious books. Evil men and women use those phrases which back their decrepit and despotic philosophies in order to further their personal wealth and designs. Good men and women use those words and phrases which advance the cause of humanity towards a better tomorrow.
Until all Muslim women have the freedom of choice to wear the hijab, I believe it is the duty of all peoples to take a stance against the use of the veil for ill.
This is a choice that Muslim women have to make. I agree that the hijab when it is worn in free choice is an idea of beauty. Humility before God (for those who believe in these religions) is an appeal to the grace of humanity. It is, indeed, a beautiful act.
The problem is that millions of men across the Muslim world use the hijab and the burqa not as an appeal to God but as a tool of personal power and in individual acts of narcissism and abhorrent nihilism. These acts are in direct contravention to the Qu’ran, the Bible and the will of God.