Harry Reid: No Apology Necessary
Posted By The Editors | January 11th, 2010 | Category: The Obama Presidency | 2 comments
Print This Post
By Karen Hunter
GOP chair Michael Steele made the rounds this weekend calling for, among other things, the resignation of Senate Majority Leader Democratic Harry Reid for comments that Reid made about Barack Obama while he was making his historic run for president.
Steele should be ashamed of himself for trying to make political hay over comments that were, well, true and could easily apply to Steele himself. Reid said Obama had a good chance to win because he was a “light-skinned” African-American “with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one.”
People are calling Reid’s comments racist. Those comments aren’t racist. Harry Reid is ignorant more than he is racist. His comments were unenlightened but held some truth.
Are light-skinned blacks not favored in America, even in the black community? If Barack Obama was the complexion of Vernon Jordan or Michael Jordan he most likely would not be president.
There is white and light-skinned favoritism in this country that permeates even the black culture. We can take it back to slavery when the field hands were separated from the house slaves based on skin color (due to white men raping slaves and producing children who then became property and would often end up in the house of the master/father).
That soon became a self-inflicted cast system among blacks post slavery. There was even a brown paper bag test to enter some fraternity, sororities and clubs in the black community where if you were darker than a brown paper bag, you couldn’t get in. In the 1950s the famous Kenneth and Mamie Phipps Clark doll test used as evidence by the Brown v. Board of Education legal team to show the harms of legal segregation, showed that the vast majority of black children preferred white over black dolls. More recently, Kiri Davis’s film “A Girl Like Me,” recreated the Clark’s study. Same results, different generation.
If you’re brown stick around…if you’re black get back.
But the nerve that Reid really touched in his ignorance was this notion of duality among blacks. In saying that Obama had “no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one,” (I would have fun, however, watching Reid try to explain exactly what is a “Negro dialect”).
Most blacks who are in corporate America or who work and live around a whites are able to talk in unaccented English and carry themselves in a different way than they do around their black family and friends. It’s second nature for some of us. (There are those like Tiger Woods and Clarence Thomas who keep it “white” all the time, however).
W.E.B. Dubois wrote about this phenomenon nearly a hundred years ago.
“It’s a peculiar sensation this double consciousness, this sense of always looking at one’s self through the eyes of others, measuring one’s soul by the tape of a world that looks on in amused contempt and pity,” wrote Dubois. “One always feels his twoness—an American, a Negro; two souls, two thoughts, two unreconciled strivings; two warring ideals in one dark body, whose dogged strength alone keeps it from being torn asunder.”
No other group in America has this sort of functional split personality and the ability to flip it on and off with such aplomb that folks like Reid who get to glimpse it are amazed.
So, yes, President Obama is light-skinned and I know he speaks in a different manner with his homies and his wife than he does when delivering a speech to the American people or speaking to Congress.
Again, if we are being honest President Barack Obama is exactly what he needed to look like and sound like to be elected in America today.
No apologies necessary. Just the truth.
Karen Hunter is a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist, best-selling author and media professor at Hunter College in New York City.
Mission Critical: Succeeding at Black America’s Last Chance
International Women’s Day: Crossing Bridges for Women Around the World
Detroit Diary: Don’t Leave Young Workers Behind
Black History Month is Over. But Should it be?
Cartoon: March 12, 2010
AIG Lenders Pay For Discriminating Against Blacks
Victory, For Now, For Gay Marriage in D.C.
“Precious” and the Oscars
We’re Not the Na’vis: The True Ecology of Avatar
The Abdication of Desirée Rogers
Top 25 African-American Films of All Time
My Top 10 African-American TV Shows of All Time
Sarah Rector: The Richest Colored Girl in the World
‘If You Learned It, Then You Should Have Got an A On It’
What the Amy Bishop Case Says About Race and Crime
‘I Can’t Believe You Brought Home a White Boy’
A Fun Face?
Chemical Relaxers: The Facts Might Not Be So Relaxing
From Orange Mint and Honey to Sins of the Mother: The Power of Story Endures
LDF Defends Chicago Black Firefighters
Is That Your Child? Mothers Talk About Rearing Biracial Children
Will the ‘Real’ Michelle Obama Please Stand Up?
Mental Health Parity 2010
Professor Hunter- very thoughtful and well written. Katie Couric did a nice blog about this as well. http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=6084286n&tag=contentMain;contentBody
Senate Majority Leader Democratic Harry Reid’s ignorance speaks against the multi-cultural ethnic origins of all U.S. Americans, diminishing the luminosity of our republic creedo, “One Nation….” Yet, what are ‘We The People’ free to be or speek like in Harry Reid’s Amerca, more American dialect (if there is such a thing) or less linguistic origin?
Is it nationally socially permissible to be duel Afro cunning linguists? Is it ‘OK’ for Irish to speak more Gaelic amongst kindreds? Can Italians exude more pride of dielect and bravdo of language, when in like company? What is so difficult to accept then, regarding the African-American, the Negro, being whosoever they esteem?
Is it ‘OK’ for the ‘Negro’ to speak or be more negro in the company of other Negroids? Sounds radically racial and silly in a dank dark chocolate acceptance of low depraved thinking depths, dosen’t it? Yet 200 years ago, this was the depraved norm, and serious racial conversations, whch led to the passing of nationally and locally mortally serious racist laws.
Today, in plain scientific fact, the Negro is the genetic Mother and Father of all humankind. There is no other derivation other then skin color with regards to the Negro or African-American in equal comparison to that of any other human kind on the planet. Senator Reid’s problem is that he does not know how important it is to relate to ‘all’ as if he were relating to ‘one.’ He sees himself as not being one of ‘U.S..’ And it is that expressed ignorance on Senator Reid’s behalf that betrays his interlectual powerlessness to rightly divide fact from cult fiction. Shame on you, Sir.
GOP chair Michael Steele. What rank humor this ‘Afro-Saxon Negro’ must possess to elicit the voluminiosity of media focus based on the ignorant outbust of a fellow esteemed political countryman? Senate Majority Leader Democratic Harry Reid, is the WYSIWYG Real McCoy (pardon the pun). Those calling for his, Reid’s, capitulation; a man who speaks plainly and simply about the observed Afro-American duelistic dialect truth, are now in universal reciprocal jeopardy; in a word, karma. GOP chair Michael Steele and others may now suffer the requested fate their accused. Irony is such a dark carthartic humorist.