No Money in the Bank: Black Women, Wealth and Assets
Posted By The Editors | March 16th, 2010 | Category: Hot Topics | 4 comments
Print This Post
By C. Nicole Mason
If the average single black woman went to the bank and withdrew her wealth, she would only withdraw $100.00. And nearly half of single black women have zero or negative wealth—meaning if they inserted their cards into an ATM machine, it would more than likely be rejected.
A new study by the Insight Center for Economic Development finds that single black women have one penny of wealth for every dollar of wealth owned by black men and only a tiny fraction of a penny for every dollar of wealth owned by white women.
Nationally, five out of ten African-American women have had trouble paying bills on time and one-third of black women are worried about their debt-to-income ratio.
In tough economic times, this news is particularly devastating as it means without wealth and assets, black women who lose their jobs or have a financial emergency will have very few reserves to draw upon to get them through.
Over the last few decades, black women have made tremendous strides in terms of educational attainment, entering careers with high income potential and homeownership. However, these gains have met with rollbacks and have not necessarily translated to wealth or assets. In fact, in the case of homeownership, black women were 256 percent more likely than white men to receive subprime loans. And upper-income black women were nearly five times more likely than white men to be saddled with high-cost mortgages.
Low-income black women and single mothers also have a difficult time accumulating wealth and savings. Black single mothers with children under 18 have a median net wealth of zero compared to $7,970 of wealth held by white women with children under the age of 18. Among black families, 68 percent of black women have no net financial savings and live from paycheck to paycheck.
The question is what keeps black women from accumulating wealth and assets? The answer is manifold.
First, there is a prevailing myth that income equals wealth. Many people measure their economic well-being by how much money they bring in the door each month. This is a mistake. While the income gap between black women and white women is relatively small, the wealth gap between the two groups is huge—$100.00 compared to $41,500.00. Income can help lay the foundation to build wealth and accumulate assets, but without access to savings and pension plans, prime financial institutions and wealth building information and resources, the likelihood that income will translate into measurable wealth is slim.
Low-income women and single mothers have it the hardest in terms of building wealth over time because much of their income is dedicated to basic necessities and child care. It is estimated that over one-third of the income of single mothers goes to child care costs while the rest is spent on housing and food, leaving very little to sock away for an emergency. For women who receive public assistance, there is a cap on how much money they can have in a savings account.
Institutional and structural barriers also exist that impede Black women’s ability to accumulate wealth. Historically, African Americans and people of color were excluded from many of the policies that allowed whites to accumulate wealth and transfer wealth and assets from generation to generation. In addition to laws and policies that restricted blacks from owning property or prevented access to quality jobs, parallel laws prevented women from owning property or obtaining credit in their names.
Occupational segmentation has also played a role in preventing black women from accumulating wealth and assets. African Americans are more likely to be segregated in occupations that are temporary in nature or service-related. These jobs generally are less flexible, have fewer benefits and lower pay. African-American women are over-represented in service occupations at 27 percent compared to white women at 17 percent and underrepresented in management level or professional positions at just over 5 percent.
Taken collectively, all of these factors have contributed to the lack of wealth and assets among black women. When we look beyond the numbers, we see that the impact is far reaching and lasting. Lack of wealth easily translates into less money to transfer to future generations, less money to help pay for her children’s education, and less money to live on in retirement, among other things.
What can be done?
Last week, Forbes magazine released its latest list of the world’s richest people. On it, there are 38 new billionaires. The wealth gap continues to not only widen, but deepen.
The wealth gap is a systemic and structural problem that took decades to create. It is not new and it did not happen overnight. Policies to correct the gap will have to address existing and entrenched structural and institutional barriers to asset and wealth accumulation from predatory lending practices to the lack of financial institutions in communities of color to discriminatory hiring practices.
In overhauling the financial system and dedicated money to economic recovery, the Administration has an extraordinary opportunity to level the playing field and ensure that all individuals have equal access to resources to help build wealth and assets.
Dr. C. Nicole Mason is the Executive Director of the Women of Color Policy Network at the Wagner School of Public Service at New York University.
Downward Mobility: The Recession’s Terrible Legacy?
Jefferson Thomas, American Hero 1942 — 2010
The “Ban The Box” Movement Scores Victories
How Injustice Works: Black and Native American Farmers Still Denied Funds by Congress
Depression and Anxiety: Is the Stuff on Your Mind Killing You
Reality and Poll Reporting are Poles Apart
The Beck-Palin Rally: Where Was The Rest of America?
Teaching Black Kids to Cope with Racism
Obama Renews Pledge to Help New Orleans Rebuild
LDF Statement Commemorating 5th Anniversary of Hurricane Katrina
Top 25 African-American Films of All Time
My Top 10 African-American TV Shows of All Time
A Fun Face?
Calvin Willis
The Red and the Black: African Americans and Cherokees in Antebellum America
Biloxi Schools Controversy: Punished for Achievement?
Clyde Murphy: 1948 — 2010
Sarah Rector: The Richest Colored Girl in the World
Chemical Relaxers: The Facts Might Not Be So Relaxing
Spike Lee revisits New Orleans in new HBO documentary
8 Year-Old Girl’s Hair Triggers Cries of Racism But Are We Jumping the Gun?
Is That Your Child? Mothers Talk About Rearing Biracial Children
No Birth Records = Tough Road Ahead When Aging Out of Foster Care
55 Years Later, Emmett Till Murder Still Haunts
Dr. Mason, thank you for this informative and disturbing article. Also, I would like to suggest that the stress of insufficient funds encourages emotional and physical illness that further depletes wealth and decreases productivity. Along with government action, perhaps churches and community groups could do even more. They are not weighed down by hostile forces as is the case, unfortunately, with our government, which seems to be caught in some sort of fight between the well-meaning-but-scared and the greedy-evil-and-shameless. I keep feeling as if I am caught in some nightmare Batman movie where the Joker too often wins.
Perhaps more affordable and free lay counseling could help stressed and traumatized women tap their own potential strengths. The psychological factor, I am convinced, is urgent.
Also, we, on the side of good, need to be increasingly inventive in sharing resources. I attended a community writers’ conference in January, and when one struggling woman said she lacked a computer, another woman was quick to tell her about a local program that would provide a refurbished computer without cost.
It would take a miracle, perhaps, to turn around the situation Dr. Mason so well maps out. But I believe we can make our own small practical miracles each day. Thank you, again for the illuminating piece.
[...] No Money in the Bank: Black Women, Wealth and Assets (The Defenders Online) [...]
[...] our finances, whether it be saving, spending, or investing. Many have probably already read the stories regarding the lack of net wealth amongst single black women, and the black community in general. Also, many of us who have the finances to do so often [...]
You were focused on Black women all through the article and at the end you lasped into that “communities of color”. Blacks household income trails ALL ETHNIC GROUPS including households of color. But, the systems made you do it … right?